SoldByOwner › Guides › Do you have to pay a buyer’s agent when you sell FSBO?
Do you have to pay a buyer’s agent when you sell FSBO?
It is the first money question every by-owner seller asks, and since August 2024 it has a cleaner answer than it used to. A buyer can absolutely bring an agent to a FSBO home — most buyers work with one — but an agent on the other side of the table is not automatically your bill. There is no listing agreement in a by-owner sale, and the listing agreement was the document that promised the buyer’s side its pay. What replaced the old system is a written agreement between the buyer and their own agent, signed before touring, and your only connection to it is what you choose to agree to inside an offer. This page covers the rule, the trade behind it, and the exact way any payment you do agree to gets written down.
1. No listing agreement, no promised pay
In an agent-listed sale, the seller signs a listing agreement and historically offered buyer-agent compensation out of it. FSBO removes that document entirely: you owe a buyer’s agent nothing by default, nothing by custom, and nothing by law. Under the practice changes that took effect August 17, 2024 with the NAR settlement, a buyer working with an agent signs a written agreement on that agent’s compensation before touring homes, and offers of compensation may no longer be advertised on the MLS. The buyer’s agent’s pay is therefore the buyer’s own obligation under their own paperwork — the buyer may ask you, inside an offer, to cover some or all of it, and your answer is simply a negotiated term of that offer, like the price or the closing date.
2. The trade: the fee comes back inside the offer
Saying no is free, but it is not weightless. A buyer who must pay their agent out of pocket brings less money to your price, so a flat refusal usually reappears as a lower offer, a concession request wearing different clothes, or an agent-represented buyer who never tours at all. The sellers who handle this best decide the number before the first showing — many offer a stated amount in their listing copy so agents and buyers know the term up front — and then judge every offer on one net sheet: price, minus any agent pay you agreed to, minus concessions, minus credits. An offer $5,000 higher that asks you to pay a $9,000 agent fee is the worse offer, and the net sheet is what shows it. Unrepresented buyers exist too; with no agent on either side, the same contract care applies, and the closing still runs through a title company or attorney.
3. If you agree to pay, it lives in the contract
Any amount you agree to pay goes in the signed purchase contract: the exact figure — a percentage of the price or a flat dollar amount — payable to the buyer’s brokerage, disbursed at closing from the sale proceeds by the settlement agent, and owed only if the sale closes. Keep it distinct from a seller concession: a concession is money toward the buyer’s own closing costs under lender rules, while agent pay is compensation to the buyer’s brokerage; an offer may ask for either or both, and the contract should name which. A figure mentioned in a listing, a yard sign or a phone call is not a promise the closing can enforce — in writing, in the contract, or it is not owed. State the term the same way in your SoldByOwner post so the buyers and agents reading it see one consistent number.
4. The saving FSBO actually promises
What by-owner selling removes is the listing side: no listing agreement, no listing commission, and the pricing, marketing and negotiation run by you. Buyer-agent pay, when you choose to offer it, is a marketing decision you make with open eyes and a net sheet — not a toll the system charges you for selling your own home. Sellers who price from real comparables, state the agent term up front, and answer offers on net keep both the saving and the buyer pool; the pricing and concessions guides linked below carry the arithmetic.
Do you have to pay a buyer’s agent when you sell FSBO?
No. Selling by owner means there is no listing agreement, and a listing agreement is the document that used to promise a buyer’s agent a fee — without one, nothing is owed to anyone’s agent by default. Since August 17, 2024, under the NAR settlement practice changes, a buyer working with an agent signs a written agreement setting that agent’s pay before touring homes. The buyer is responsible for it under their own agreement; in an offer, the buyer may ask you to pay some or all of it, as a seller concession or a direct contract term. You can say yes, no, or part of it — it is a negotiated price term, not a rule, a custom you must follow, or a fee set by law.
What happens if a FSBO seller offers a buyer’s agent nothing?
The buyer’s agent is still paid — by the buyer, under the written buyer agreement the buyer signed before touring, unless the buyer negotiates a different arrangement with their own agent. What changes is the arithmetic of the buyer’s offer: money the buyer must bring to pay their agent is money not available for your price, so a no-pay stance usually comes back inside the offer as a lower price, a concession request in another form, or a buyer who cannot stretch to your number. Some buyers, especially experienced ones, tour without an agent at all. Weighing an agent-represented offer against others, compare every offer on the same net sheet — price minus everything you are asked to pay — never on the headline price alone.
How do you pay a buyer’s agent on a FSBO sale, in writing?
In the purchase contract itself: the exact amount — a percentage of the price or a flat dollar figure — who it is payable to (the buyer’s brokerage), and that it is paid at closing from the sale proceeds through the settlement agent, only if the sale closes. Alternatively, the offer may frame the same money as a seller concession toward the buyer’s costs, which the buyer then uses under their own agreement; the two are different mechanics with different lender rules, so the contract should say plainly which one it is. Never rely on a verbal promise or a figure mentioned in a listing — if it is not in the signed contract, it is not owed, and if it is in the contract, it is.
For a FSBO seller that means: post your home free — no fees, no contract, take it down any time — in your own photos and your own words, and it is seen by buyers browsing SoldByOwner and by 6,600 realtors with buyers. SoldByOwner’s realtor directory lists 829 local pros from the Realtor Referral Hub roster, so a buyer’s agent is easy to find on the other side of the table too.
Post your home freeThe costs a FSBO seller does and does not pay are set out in Who pays closing costs on a FSBO sale, the concession alternative is covered in What are seller concessions on a FSBO sale, and the definition underneath it all is in What does FSBO mean.