SoldByOwner › Guides › How do you respond to a lowball offer on a FSBO home
How do you respond to a lowball offer on a FSBO home?
A lowball offer feels like an insult and reads like data. It is a buyer telling you, in writing, what they think the home is worth and what they are willing to be held to — and on a by-owner sale you are the agent who has to answer it, which means the answer is a professional document, not a reaction. The sellers who handle lowballs well do four things in order: they read the whole offer instead of just the price, they re-check their own price before replying, they counter once in writing at a number the evidence defends, and they know the point at which the right answer is a polite no. None of it requires a listing agent — it requires the same discipline an agent would bring, applied by you.
1. Read the whole offer, not just the price
Price is one line of the offer; the net is the whole page. Read the financing first — cash, a preapproval with a named lender, or a prequalification letter are three different offers wearing the same price. Then the earnest money, the contingency list and its deadlines, the closing date, and every concession or credit the buyer is asking you to fund. A low price with cash, real earnest money, no sale-of-home contingency, and a fast close can net you more — and close more certainly — than a higher offer stacked with contingencies and seller-paid costs. Do the arithmetic both ways, on the settlement numbers, before you decide the offer is low.
2. Re-check your own price before you answer
A lowball is sometimes a buyer testing you, and sometimes the market correcting you — and the reply differs completely. Go back to the recent sold homes your price was built on: three to five comparable sales, nearby, recent, like-for-like. If they still defend your number, your counter can stand on evidence, and you should attach it — a one-page comp sheet answers a low offer better than any adjective. If the fresh sales have moved under you, the offer is a pricing signal, not an insult; answer this buyer honestly and take the price question up separately, because the next buyer will run the same numbers.
3. Counter once, in writing, at a defensible number
Never reject a written offer outright — a rejection ends the only negotiation you have, and a counter costs you nothing. Counter in writing, on the contract form, with an expiration: a counter without a deadline is an invitation to shop your number. Move on terms before price where you can — the closing date, the concessions asked, inclusions, the earnest money, a shorter inspection window — and when you do move on price, move to the number the comparables support, not to a split-the-difference midpoint, which defends nothing and invites the next split. One clear counter, with the comp sheet attached and a short factual note, tells a serious buyer exactly where the floor of the evidence sits.
4. Know when the answer is a polite no
Some lowballs are a strategy with no second step: the buyer counters nothing, repeats the number, or asks you to bid against yourself. After one documented counter, the burden of movement is theirs. Decline in writing, briefly and professionally, and leave the door named and open — if their position changes, your counter stands until its deadline and the home is still being shown. What you never do is chase: a sequence of small unilateral cuts to meet a stuck buyer teaches every other buyer watching that your price is soft, and it spends the reduction you may need for a real negotiation. The home stays on the market, the marketing keeps running, and the next offer is answered the same way.
How do you respond to a lowball offer on a FSBO home?
Read the whole offer first — financing strength, earnest money, contingencies, closing date, and concessions asked — and compute the net, because a low price on clean terms can beat a higher fragile offer. Re-check your asking price against recent comparable sales. Then counter once, in writing, with a deadline, at the number the comparables defend, trading terms before price and attaching the comp sheet. Never reject a written offer outright, and never negotiate the number verbally.
Should you reject a lowball offer on a FSBO home outright?
No. A flat rejection ends the only negotiation you have and costs the buyer nothing to walk away from, while a written counter costs you nothing and forces the buyer to show whether they can move. Even a buyer who opens far under asking sometimes closes near it; the ones who cannot move reveal it by answering your counter with nothing. Decline only after a documented counter has been met with no movement — in writing, briefly, with the door left open.
How far above a lowball offer should a FSBO seller counter?
Counter from the evidence, not from the gap. Splitting the difference defends nothing and invites the next split. Price your counter off the recent comparable sales and your net after the offer’s own terms — concessions, credits, and costs the buyer asks you to carry — and be ready to show that arithmetic. If the comparables support your asking price, countering at or near it, with terms traded instead, is a stronger and more honest answer than a token cut.
For a FSBO seller that means: post your home free — no fees, no contract, take it down any time — in your own photos and your own words, and it is seen by buyers browsing SoldByOwner and by 6,600 realtors with buyers. SoldByOwner’s realtor directory lists 829 local pros from the Realtor Referral Hub roster, so a buyer’s agent is easy to find on the other side of the table too.
Post your home freeThe documents a FSBO closing runs on are listed in What paperwork do you need to sell a house FSBO, the day itself runs as in What happens on closing day for a FSBO sale, and the copies you keep afterwards are set out in What records should you keep after selling a FSBO home.