SoldByOwner

SoldByOwner › Guides › How much earnest money should a FSBO seller ask for?

How much earnest money should a FSBO seller ask for?

Earnest money is the buyer's good-faith deposit — the cash that backs the signature on the contract. On a FSBO sale there is no listing broker's trust account in the middle, so the seller sets the amount, names who holds it, and lives by the contract's refund rules. Get those three things right and the deposit does its job quietly: it keeps casual buyers out, compensates you if a committed buyer defaults, and costs a serious buyer nothing, because at closing it is simply part of their own money.

1. What earnest money actually does

Three jobs. It proves commitment — a buyer with real money down behaves differently from a buyer with none. It prices your risk — while the contract runs, your home is effectively off the market for the weeks the contingencies and the lender need, and the deposit is what stands behind that time. And it pre-agrees the remedy — if the buyer defaults outside the contract's protections, the contract's earnest-money clause, not a fresh argument, says what happens to the money. What earnest money is not: a second price, a fee you earn for signing, or money you can spend. Until a closing or a contract-defined forfeiture, it is the buyer's money sitting with a neutral holder.

2. How much: the 1–3% working range

Most FSBO contracts land at 1% to 3% of the purchase price — $4,000 to $12,000 on a $400,000 home — negotiated between the parties and shaped by local custom; no law sets the number. What moves it inside the range: a long time to closing (more of your market time at risk — ask toward the top); contingencies waived or shortened (a buyer giving up protections often pairs it with a stronger deposit); a hot market with competing buyers (deposits rise with competition); and the buyer's financing (a financed buyer is also assembling a down payment and closing costs in cash, so a deposit demand far above local custom mostly filters out ordinary buyers, not unserious ones). A staged deposit — a standard amount at signing, increased when the contingencies come off — splits the difference and is common on longer contracts. Whichever shape you choose, write it as an exact dollar amount in the contract, not a percentage to be calculated later.

3. Who holds it, and when it is due

Never you. The deposit goes to a neutral third party — in most FSBO sales the title company or the closing attorney, held in escrow — named in the contract along with the amount and the due date. Due a few days after both sides sign is the usual pattern; the exact deadline is a contract term, so put a date on it. Get written confirmation from the holder that the deposit arrived, and treat a missed earnest-money deadline as what it is: the first default signal a contract gives you, arriving early enough to act on. Holding the money yourself destroys the arrangement's whole value — you become a party holding the other side's cash, every refund conversation becomes a dispute about your honesty, and in a number of states an unlicensed seller holding deposits steps into rules written for brokers.

4. Refunded or kept: the contract decides

While a contingency is inside its deadline, a buyer who exits the way the contract allows — a failed inspection response, financing denied, a low appraisal under an appraisal contingency — normally recovers the deposit in full. After the deadlines pass, the balance flips: a buyer who then defaults, misses closing, or simply walks away risks the deposit, and many contracts treat it as the seller's agreed damages for the lost market time. Two cautions. The escrow holder releases disputed money only on both sides' signed instructions or a court's order, so a deposit is leverage and a defined claim, not instant cash. And state law and the contract form vary — the default and earnest-money clauses are the two paragraphs to read before signing, or to have your closing attorney read, because they decide what the deposit is actually worth.

5. Reading a deposit inside an offer

Judge the deposit together with the rest of the package, the way the negotiation guide in this series reads offers whole. A 3% deposit from a buyer with verified funds and a firm pre-approval is a strong signal. A large deposit from an unverified buyer, paired with long contingencies and a distant closing, can be a promise the contract lets them unwind — the deposit is only at risk once the deadlines that protect the buyer have passed. If two offers are close on price, the one whose deposit structure puts more money genuinely at risk, sooner, is usually the safer contract.

What SoldByOwner is — and is not

SoldByOwner has no MLS feed and never will. No IDX, no scraped listings, no republished MLS photos or descriptions. The homes here are permissioned only: homeowner submissions, realtor submissions with an advertising-rights attestation, and builder, auction, or foreclosure sources only where the terms allow reuse. The sample homes in the preview feed are labeled as samples.

For a FSBO seller that means: post your home free — no fees, no contract, take it down any time — in your own photos and your own words, and it is seen by buyers browsing SoldByOwner and by 6,600 realtors with buyers. SoldByOwner's realtor directory lists 829 local pros from the Realtor Referral Hub roster, so a buyer's agent is easy to find on the other side of the table too.

What it costs

Posting a home on SoldByOwner is free, and browsing is free — no seller or buyer pays SoldByOwner anything to look or to list. Money only moves if a sale closes through a network referral, under the split agreed in writing before details move: a bench receiver pays 30% of the referred side's commission in total (25% to the sender and 5% to the desk for paperwork and tracking); a Premium lock-holder receiving in their own metro pays 25% to the sender only.

Post your home free

Reading the whole offer: How do you negotiate an offer on a FSBO home? — and the clauses around the deposit: What contingencies should a FSBO contract include?