SoldByOwner › Guides › How do you choose a title company for a FSBO sale?
How do you choose a title company for a FSBO sale?
In an agent-listed sale, somebody’s agent picks the closing office and the seller rarely thinks about it. In a FSBO sale that somebody is you — and the choice matters more, because the title company (or, in attorney states, the closing attorney working with one) is the neutral professional who holds the money, searches the title, issues the insurance and records the deed on a deal where neither side has an agent coordinating. Pick it before the contract is signed, on checks you can verify, and write its name into the contract. This page is the five checks, the who-chooses rule, and the timing.
1. Authority and the underwriter
Start with the license. A title company should be licensed or regulated in your state — your state’s insurance department or financial-services regulator is the lookup — and it should name, without hesitation, the title insurer that underwrites the policies it issues. The underwriter is the balance sheet standing behind your owner’s policy and the buyer’s lender’s policy; a known national or strong regional underwriter is what lenders expect to see on the commitment. A company that will not say who underwrites it has failed the first check.
2. FSBO experience, asked out loud
Ask the exact question: do you close for-sale-by-owner deals, with a seller who has no agent, as a routine part of your work? By-owner closings are not harder closings, but they are different in one way — there is no agent translating the process, ordering pieces, or chasing signatures. The right office expects that, hands the seller its own checklist of what it needs and when, and does not treat an unrepresented seller as a problem to be managed. Offices that mostly serve agent pipelines sometimes do the opposite; you will hear it in the first phone call.
3. The written quote, compared line by line
Get two or three quotes in writing before you sign a contract, each itemized the same way: the settlement or closing fee, the title search charge, the owner’s policy premium, the lender’s policy premium if you are being asked to pay it, and the add-ons — courier, wire, document preparation, e-recording, notary. In many states title insurance premiums are set or filed by the state, which means the premium lines come out the same at every company and the honest comparison is the settlement fee and the extras. Keep the quote you accepted; the closing statement should reconcile to it, and a line that appears at closing but never appeared in the quote is a question to ask before you sign, in writing.
4. Money handling you can verify
The company holds the buyer’s earnest money in its escrow account — never in yours — and disburses at closing only against the signed documents. Money movement is also where closing fraud lives, so one habit is non-negotiable: wire instructions count only when you verify them by phone, at a number you looked up yourself, with a person at the company. Instructions that arrive by email alone — however official the letterhead — are not verified instructions, for your payoff funds or the buyer’s. A company with a real verification procedure will say so itself; that answer is part of the check.
5. A named contact and a written timeline
Finally, process. You want one named person who owns your file, a written timeline from contract to closing — search ordered, commitment back, payoff figures requested, closing scheduled — and communication in days rather than weeks. FSBO sellers carry the coordination an agent would normally carry; the closing office’s responsiveness is the difference between carrying it calmly and carrying it at midnight before closing day. Ask what it needs from you at the start, and hold it to the list it gives you.
How do you choose a title company for a FSBO sale?
Name the company in the purchase contract, and choose it on five checks. First, authority: it should be licensed or regulated in your state, and it should tell you which title insurer underwrites the policies it issues. Second, FSBO experience: ask directly whether it closes by-owner deals with unrepresented sellers as a routine — a good FSBO closing office expects a seller with no agent and hands you the checklist instead of assuming one exists. Third, a written itemized quote before you sign: settlement or closing fee, title search, the owner’s and lender’s policy premiums, and every add-on — courier, wire, document preparation, e-recording. In many states the premiums are set or filed by the state, so they match across companies and the settlement fee is the real comparison. Fourth, money handling: earnest money sits in its escrow account, never yours, and its wire instructions are ones you verify by phone at a number you look up yourself. Fifth, process: a named contact, a written timeline, and answers in days, not weeks.
Who chooses the title company in a FSBO sale?
Whoever the contract says — it is a negotiated term, not a rule. Local custom is the starting point: in many places the party who pays for the owner’s title policy proposes the company, and in some the buyer’s side traditionally does. In attorney states, a real estate attorney may run the closing while a title company still handles the search, the insurance and often the escrow, so the question there is which attorney and which title company. One federal fence applies either way: under RESPA Section 9 (12 U.S.C. 2608), a seller may not require a buyer who is taking a federally related mortgage loan to buy title insurance from a particular title company. Agree the company — and who pays which of its charges — in the contract itself, before the search is ordered.
When should a FSBO seller pick the title company?
Before the purchase contract is signed — the contract names the settlement agent, sets who holds the earnest money, and starts the title search clock. Choosing after signing means renegotiating a term both sides already settled, usually under time pressure from the closing date. Get the written quotes while you are still marketing the home if you can, the way you would line up any other closing professional; the company you pick can also tell you, before an offer arrives, what it needs from a by-owner seller and what its typical timeline runs from contract to closing. If an offer names a company you have never heard of, run the same five checks before you sign — a buyer’s suggestion is a proposal, not an instruction.
For a FSBO seller that means: post your home free — no fees, no contract, take it down any time — in your own photos and your own words, and it is seen by buyers browsing SoldByOwner and by 6,600 realtors with buyers. SoldByOwner’s realtor directory lists 829 local pros from the Realtor Referral Hub roster, so a buyer’s agent is easy to find on the other side of the table too.
Post your home freeWhat the title company actually does at the table is covered in How does closing work on a FSBO sale, what its charges sit alongside is set out in Who pays closing costs on a FSBO sale, and the policy it issues is explained in the closing-day guide, What happens on closing day for a FSBO sale.