SoldByOwner › Guides › How to respond to a counteroffer on a FSBO home
How to respond to a counteroffer on a FSBO home
A counteroffer is a decision, not a discussion. The moment you counter, the buyer's offer is gone — replaced by yours — and the deal lives or dies on how the counter is written: on the state form, with every term stated, a deadline on it, and an answer inside a day or two. FSBO sellers lose deals here not on price but on paper: a verbal counter nobody can enforce, a deadline nobody stated, a repair promise nobody priced. Here is the sequence that keeps a negotiation enforceable at every step.
1. A counteroffer replaces the offer — it does not sit beside it
Legally, a counteroffer rejects the original offer and replaces it. The buyer's offer, at the buyer's price and terms, no longer exists once you counter — and the party who was countered cannot revive the original by simply saying yes to it later. The same rule runs the other way on the next round: the buyer's counter kills your counter. That is why each round is a fresh decision, not a tweak. It also means a counter can be withdrawn before acceptance, even before its stated deadline — deliver the withdrawal in writing — while a counter that has been signed and accepted in time is a contract and cannot be withdrawn at all. And an unaccepted counter expires on its own at its deadline; after that there is nothing on the table for either side.
2. Every counter in writing, on the form, with a deadline
Put the counter on your state's purchase contract or counteroffer form, signed, with the changed price and every changed term written out — and a stated acceptance deadline on the counter itself. Nothing material stays on the phone: a price agreed in a call and never written into a signed counter is not agreed. Work at the pace deals move: respond inside the 24–48 hour working window. A counter that sits for four days tells the buyer the seller is hoping for something better, and buyers answer that signal by making offers on other homes. Keep the deadline short for the same reason — an open counter is the seller's home held off the market at the buyer's option, for free.
3. Negotiate the terms, not just the price
Price is one line of the deal; the terms decide whether it closes. Counter on contingency clocks — the number of days for inspection, appraisal, and financing, and what happens when one lapses. Counter on earnest money — a larger deposit, due sooner, held by the title company in escrow, is a buyer's seriousness stated in dollars. Counter on the closing date and possession, including a rent-back if your own move needs one. And settle the repair question the way closings can actually execute it: a credit stated as exact dollars, or a repair stated as exact dollars and exact scope — never an open promise to fix "the issues." Trading a modest price concession for a shorter inspection clock or a closing date that fits your move routinely nets a seller more than winning the last price round and losing the deal at a blown deadline.
4. With multiple offers: one deadline, every buyer told
Two or more live offers change the procedure, not the honesty. Notify all buyers (through their agents where they have them) that multiple offers are in hand, and set one highest-and-best deadline that applies to every buyer equally — same deadline, same message, no side terms whispered to a favorite. Then compare the counters on the full term sheet, not the headline price: deposit size, contingency clocks, financing strength, and closing date routinely outweigh a small price edge. Remember the withdrawal rule while you run it: if your own signed counter is still open with one buyer, withdraw it in writing before accepting another offer, so two contracts never exist on the same home at once.
What SoldByOwner is — and is not
SoldByOwner has no MLS feed and never will. No IDX, no scraped listings, no republished MLS photos or descriptions. The homes here are permissioned only: homeowner submissions, realtor submissions with an advertising-rights attestation, and builder, auction, or foreclosure sources only where the terms allow reuse. The sample homes in the preview feed are labeled as samples.
For a FSBO seller that means: post your home free — no fees, no contract, take it down any time — in your own photos and your own words, and it is seen by buyers browsing SoldByOwner and by 6,600 realtors with buyers. SoldByOwner's realtor directory lists 829 local pros from the Realtor Referral Hub roster, so a buyer's agent is easy to find on the other side of the table too.
What it costs
Posting a home on SoldByOwner is free, and browsing is free — no seller or buyer pays SoldByOwner anything to look or to list. Money only moves if a sale closes through a network referral, under the split agreed in writing before details move: a bench receiver pays 30% of the referred side's commission in total (25% to the sender and 5% to the desk for paperwork and tracking); a Premium lock-holder receiving in their own metro pays 25% to the sender only.
Post your home freeSelling with a tenant still in place while the offers come in? Can you sell a FSBO home with a tenant in it? — and if the deal you countered into dies before closing: What to do when a FSBO sale falls through