SoldByOwner

SoldByOwner › Guides › What is title insurance on a FSBO sale

What is title insurance on a FSBO sale

Short answer: title insurance is a one-time-premium policy issued at closing that protects against financial loss from title defects that existed before the sale but escaped the title search — forged deeds, unknown heirs, unreleased liens, recording errors. The lender's policy protects only the buyer's lender; the owner's policy protects the buyer for as long as they own the home. Who pays for each is set by the contract and local custom. General information, not legal advice.

1. The search finds what it can — the policy answers for the rest

Every closing runs a title search, and a careful search catches most problems while they can still be cured: the unreleased mortgage, the recorded judgment, the tax lien. But a search reads the record as the record exists, and some defects are invisible inside it — a signature forged well enough to pass, a deed indexed under the wrong name at the county, an heir whose interest never appeared in any probate, a prior deed signed by someone impersonating the owner. No examiner can find what the record itself hides. Title insurance exists for exactly that residue: the insurer stands behind the search it underwrote, and if a covered defect surfaces after closing, the loss and the legal defense belong to the insurer rather than to the insured owner. That is the whole product — not a second search, but a promise that the first one's misses are the insurer's problem.

2. Two policies, two insured parties — and the seller's own old policy

A financed sale writes two policies off one search. The lender's policy protects the lender's loan and nothing else; it is not the buyer's coverage and it is not the seller's. The owner's policy protects the buyer for the full purchase price for as long as they hold the home. The seller is insured by neither new policy — the seller's protection at closing is the closing itself, with every payoff made and every release recorded. But a seller who bought an owner's policy when they purchased the home still holds it: that policy stays in force for their whole ownership, and if a defect that predates their own purchase surfaces during the sale — a claim rooted in an earlier link of the chain — the seller's own policy from their purchase is the one to notify, in writing, before conceding or paying anything. Sellers routinely forget they own this policy; it sits in the closing file from their purchase, which is where to look for it.

3. The commitment is the policy in draft

The policies do not appear from nowhere at the closing table. The sequence runs search, then commitment, then closing, then policy: the title company searches the records, issues the commitment stating what it will insure and on what terms, the parties satisfy the commitment's requirements at closing, the deed records, and the policies issue on the commitment's terms — its exceptions become the policy's exceptions. A party who wants to know what a title policy will and will not cover does not wait for the policy; they read the commitment, which is the same document a week or more earlier, while its terms can still be negotiated, cured or questioned. What a title commitment is covers that document schedule by schedule — the facts it states, the requirements it lists, and the exceptions it carries into the finished policy.

4. Who pays is custom plus contract — so a FSBO contract names it

There is no national rule for who pays for title insurance, and the customs genuinely conflict: in some markets the seller provides the owner's policy as part of proving marketable title, in others the buyer buys it, and in some the parties split the policies along the line of who each one protects. Premiums are set by state regulation or filed rates in some states and negotiated in the market in others. For an agent-listed sale, the local custom usually arrives inside the standard contract form without anyone discussing it. A by-owner sale has no such autopilot: if the purchase agreement is silent, the question surfaces in closing week as a dispute about a charge neither side budgeted. The fix is one sentence at signing — which policies will issue, and who pays for each — agreed while every other term is being agreed. A seller who is providing the owner's policy should also say so in the listing conversation, because buyers price the offer against the whole closing, not the headline number alone.

5. Cash sales: the one closing with no default policy

A cash buyer has no lender, so no lender's policy is required, and nothing forces an owner's policy either. That makes the cash closing the one sale where title insurance is a pure decision — and the decision deserves a clear head, because the cash buyer is the buyer with the most of their own money in the property and no lender's examiner standing behind them. Skipping the owner's policy does not make the title better or worse; it only decides who carries the record risk. If a hidden defect surfaces in five years — the unknown heir, the forged deed two owners back — an uninsured cash buyer pays the lawyers and the settlement personally. A seller cannot make the buyer's choice for them, but a seller who offers to provide the owner's policy on a cash sale is offering the one piece of paper that answers the risk, and experienced cash buyers read that offer as a sign the seller's title is what the seller says it is.

6. After closing: the policy goes in the permanent file

The issued policies arrive after the deed records, and they belong in the permanent closing file beside the commitment, the settlement statement and the payoff statements. The owner's policy has no expiration while the buyer owns the home, and it is not cancelled by paying off the mortgage — the lender's policy ends with the loan, the owner's policy does not. If a claim ever arrives — a letter asserting an interest in the property, a lien notice rooted in the years before the sale — the insured's move is to notify the insurer in writing promptly and let the insurer defend, not to pay or concede first and ask afterward; the policy's defense duty is half of what the premium bought. Keep the insurer's name and the policy number with the file: decades can pass between the policy date and the claim, and the file is what makes the coverage findable when it is needed. State law and filed policy forms vary. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

None of this needs the MLS — SoldByOwner never lists a home on the MLS. SoldByOwner posts your home free, in your own photos and words, in front of buyers and the 6,600 realtors with buyers and 829 directory pros who browse the permissioned feed — and the home is never listed on the MLS, ever. A title policy issued on a clean commitment is part of a clean by-owner closing, so a seller treats the commitment as the draft of the policy while the feed keeps working for the next seller.

What is title insurance on a FSBO sale?

Title insurance is an insurance policy, issued at closing by a title insurer through the title company or closing attorney handling the sale, that protects the insured party against financial loss from defects in the property's title that already existed when the policy issued. The defects it answers are record problems: a forged deed or a deed executed by someone without authority somewhere in the chain of title, an heir of a prior owner who never signed off, a mortgage, judgment or tax lien recorded against a prior owner and never released, a deed or release recorded or indexed incorrectly, or an error the public records themselves carry. The insurer's duty runs both ways: it pays covered losses up to the policy amount and it defends the insured title in court when a covered claim is made. The premium is paid once, at closing — there are no ongoing payments — and an owner's policy stays in force as long as the insured or their heirs own the property. Title insurance insures the past: unlike homeowner's insurance, which covers future damage to the building, it covers what the public record already held on the day the policy issued.

What is the difference between an owner's policy and a lender's policy on a FSBO sale?

They insure different people against the same title. The lender's policy insures the buyer's mortgage lender and no one else: the lender requires it as a condition of making the loan, it covers the amount of the loan, and its coverage shrinks as the loan is paid down and ends when the loan is paid off or refinanced. The owner's policy insures the buyer: it covers the purchase price, it does not shrink as the mortgage is paid, and it lasts as long as the buyer or the buyer's heirs hold title. A buyer who relies on the lender's policy alone is uninsured — if a defect surfaces, the lender's claim is paid and the buyer's own equity is not. When both policies issue from the same search at the same closing, the owner's policy is priced as an addition to the lender's policy rather than as a second full examination, which is why the decision is made at closing and not later: an owner's policy cannot simply be added afterward on the original search once the moment has passed. Which party pays for each policy is a contract term governed by local custom, and on a by-owner sale it should be written into the purchase agreement in plain words rather than assumed.

Does a FSBO seller have to provide title insurance, and what does it not cover?

No law requires a seller to provide an owner's policy in most states, but the practical answer is set by the contract, the buyer's lender and local custom together. A financed buyer will have a lender's policy on the sale whether the seller thinks about it or not, because the lender requires it. The owner's policy is the negotiable one: in many markets custom puts it on the seller as part of delivering marketable title, in others the buyer purchases it, and a by-owner contract should name who provides it, because a FSBO seller has no listing agent carrying the local custom into the paperwork. A cash sale has no lender and no required policy at all, so the owner's policy is the buyer's own decision — and a seller's willingness to provide one is often part of how a cash buyer judges the sale's solidity. What title insurance does not cover matters as much: matters listed as exceptions in the commitment and carried into the policy, defects the buyer knew about before closing, conditions that arise after the policy date, and matters the policy's exceptions leave out. The exceptions are printed in the policy itself, which is why the commitment is read before closing rather than the policy after it.