What is the best smart lock for a new homeowner?
For most new homeowners, the deciding factor is key control, not features. On day one you can't know how many copies of the old key exist, so a keypad deadbolt — the Schlage Encode Plus, typically $250–$320 — replaces the lock and the unknown keys in one install, then hands out codes instead of copies. A code can be changed or deleted when a cleaner, sitter, or guest no longer needs access; a copied key can't be un-copied. If you want to keep your existing deadbolt and outside hardware, a retrofit lock replaces only the inside half and keeps your current key as the backup — pair it with a rekey if the house just changed hands.
Decision 1: replace the whole lock, or just the inside half
Full replacement swaps the whole deadbolt: new keyway, new keys, a keypad outside, and no connection to whoever held the old key. It is the complete fix, and the right default when the lock is being changed anyway. Retrofit replaces only the inside half — your existing deadbolt, outside hardware, and current key all keep working, and the smart part bolts on indoors. Retrofit is the pick when the hardware is worth keeping, when a landlord or HOA controls how the door looks from outside, or when you want the old key as a physical backup. One caution: a retrofit alone does not retire old key copies, because the cylinder doesn't change — if the house just changed hands, rekey first, then retrofit.
See the smart locks in the store →Decision 2: codes are the real product
The feature that changes daily life is not the app — it is the code. A spare key with a neighbor, or under the mat, is access you can't revoke. A code is access you can: give the cleaner, the dog walker, and the visiting family each their own, see which code opened the door and when, and delete a code the day it stops being needed. Auto-lock — the door locking itself a few seconds after it closes — quietly fixes the most common lock failure of all, which is forgetting to lock it.
Decision 3: Wi-Fi built in, or battery life
Locks with Wi-Fi built in — the Schlage Encode Plus is one — can be locked, unlocked, and checked from anywhere with no extra hardware, and they pay for it in batteries: expect a fresh set every few months. Bluetooth and hub-based locks use far less power and can run a year or more on a set, but remote access depends on a hub or a home-platform device in range. Pick by habit: if you will actually check the door from work or lock it from the airport, take Wi-Fi and keep spare batteries in the drawer. If the codes at the door are the whole point, take the battery life.
Where it fits in the first week
A smart lock is on the short list of first-week purchases for a new home — see what to buy first when you move into a new house. It pairs with the video doorbell: the lock controls who can open the door, the doorbell shows you who tried. Both go on with a screwdriver before the first box is unpacked, and both close the gap left by keys you can't account for.
Price bands in these answers are typical prices, checked November 2026. The retailer sets the price you pay.
For Your Home is a curated store of physical products homeowners buy, sold through affiliate links (Amazon Associates, tag foryourhom079-20) — the store earns a commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to the buyer. More answers in the Homeowner Guide.